Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Holly Starley's avatar

Well, Jill, this was an absolute delight to listen to. Brought me back to near botched public transit journeys of my own. In fact, it reminded me of once such an Ecuador I will soon write about.

I’ve been thinking a lot about voice in writing lately. And I just have to say yours is truly wonderful. Not sure who pointed me to you, but I’m very glad they did. :)

Expand full comment
Mills Baker's avatar

“Even a man without qualities has a father with qualities” is a Musil chapter title I think of a lot; love that guy, long books though! Also couldn’t agree more about Cusk, whom I like a lot despite it, but: absolutely lol.

When Abby came with me to the UK, we discussed how everyone says “sorry”; it’s not unheard of in the American South, and Abby and I both apologize for events far from our control constantly. For what it’s worth, we both love it in the UK. Everyone should be sorry! We all have a lot to be sorry for. We’re still, even in England, probably apologizing less than half the amount we should. When you talked to that dickhead German and found a way to be compassionate thinking of his possible particulars, that was the spiritual side of automatic “I’m sorry”-ing and it’s often beautiful! You didn’t stop him from learning English! You didn’t suggest it’s bad not to know English! But: you’re sorry he’s in that spot (maybe) and you were cooler to him than others might have been because of it!

I’m sorry for defending saying “I’m sorry.” I know it’s neurotic and that I’m neurotic. I’m a weird person, but FWIW I leave eunuchs alone.

Expand full comment
28 more comments...

No posts